Browse the archive

Historic event / crime

Historic event / crime case files: historic context, historical accounts, sources, and access cautions from the archive.

Warner's Ranch trading post site

⌖ Warner Springs area, California

Historic event / crimeStatus unconfirmed

Established in 1849, Warner's trading post was destroyed during the Garra uprising of 1851. The uprising unfolded amid disputes over taxation and encroachment. At Warner's ranch, buildings were burned, the store was looted and livestock were taken. The Historic American Buildings Survey and Stephen R. Van Wormer and Susan D. Walter's 2011 archaeological study date the attack to November 22 and record one member of Warner's party killed. SOHO's exhibit gives a different account: November 21, with two employees killed. Accounts from 1852 and 1853 describe ruins. Warner's destroyed house-and-store site was distinct from the surviving Warner-Carrillo adobe, a distinction clarified by the 2011 archaeological study.

◯ General area onlyOpen case file →

Jacumba Valley massacre site

⌖ Jacumba Hot Springs area, California

Historic event / crimeStatus unconfirmed

In February 1880, cattlemen pursued people accused of taking cattle in the Jacumba area. The San Diego Union's February 28 report described a McCain boy being killed, the pursuers retreating, and a military response. Mike Connolly's history identifies William McCain as the son of George McCain. William's death became part of conflicting accounts of what is remembered as the Jacumba Massacre. In a 1991 Calexico Chronicle article, Peter R. Odens reported that William's gravestone recorded February 27, 1880, and an age of 17. The inherited accounts he recorded disagree about the sequence of attack and retaliation.

◯ General area onlyOpen case file →

Bush and Ivey shooting, Julian area

⌖ Julian, California

Historic event / crimeStatus unconfirmed

The shooting of John Ivey in the Julian area of San Diego County led to a murder case against J. J. Bush. In 1884, the California Supreme Court reversed Bush’s murder conviction over improper evidence and an erroneous self-defense instruction. A later trial resulted in a first-degree murder conviction. The jury had visited the shooting site in 1884 without Bush present. In 1886, the California Supreme Court reversed the conviction and ordered a new trial because that visit had taken place in his absence.

◯ General area onlyOpen case file →

Moosa Canyon ranch gunfight site

⌖ Moosa Canyon, California

Historic event / crimeStatus unconfirmed

On January 18, 1888, an attempted eviction at Stone's bee ranch in Moosa Canyon ended in a gunfight. A posse led by Breedlove was involved in the confrontation, which left four people dead. Burnham, Going and McCarnahan/McConahay died that day, according to county coroner records. Reed also died in connection with the gunfight, although accounts differ on when. The sheriff asked artist Isaac Jenkinson Frazee to sketch the scene.

◯ General area onlyOpen case file →

Sandrock's store, Mission Valley

⌖ Mission Valley, San Diego, California

Historic event / crimeStatus unconfirmed

Anne A. Sandrock was a German-born merchant, aged 53, whose Mission Valley store also served as a dwelling. She was killed there on October 5, 1895. The next day's San Diego Union and Daily Bee reported injuries to her head and throat, a medical examination and an inquest held that night. The Union reported a finding of murder. The inquest account later reproduced by the San Diego Reader described wounds inflicted by parties unknown. By October 10, the Union reported that Jose Rosa and Ramon Meche had been captured at Descanso and jailed in San Diego, but emphasized that there was very little evidence against them.

◯ General area onlyOpen case file →

Mesa Grande mountainside posse shootout

⌖ Mesa Grande, California

Historic event / crimeStatus unconfirmed

In September 1895, a posse pursued Ysidro Renterias after he wounded Ramon Arisa on September 6. Constable Hubbert and deputized citizen Juan Castro took part in the pursuit, which the Oceanside Blade described as lasting nine days. It ended in a confrontation at Mesa Grande, where Castro and Renterias died. The Blade’s narrative places the confrontation on a Saturday. Robert Bowling’s 2022 account instead dates it to Sunday, September 15, and describes a pursuit of nearly ten days. Both accounts tell of Castro’s death during the effort to capture Renterias. The Blade reported that an inquest the following day justified Hubbert’s actions. Both the Blade and the San Francisco Call credited him with killing Renterias. Bowling’s later account gives a different interpretation: it reports that the inquest found Hubbert’s bullet had not killed Renterias and infers simultaneous shots involving Castro.

◯ General area onlyOpen case file →

Otay Valley flood zone, Lower Otay Dam failure

⌖ San Ysidro, California

Historic event / crimeStatus unconfirmed

On January 27, 1916, Lower Otay Dam was overtopped during the Southern California floods. Its steel diaphragm failed at 5:05 p.m., sending floodwater downstream into the Otay Valley and affecting Palm City. The disaster killed at least 20 people in the Otay Valley, according to the San Diego History Center. Japanese residents were among the victims; the South Bay Historical Society reproduces an account of eleven Japanese victims who were memorialized. Eight officers and 85 enlisted Navy and Marine personnel took part in a two-week relief effort. Their service district included San Ysidro and the Tijuana border area, extending the response beyond the Otay Valley itself.

◯ General area onlyOpen case file →

Temecula Massacre battlefield, Pauba Valley

⌖ Temecula, California

Historic event / crimeStatus unconfirmed

The Temecula Massacre was an ambush of Luiseño people in Pauba Valley. Great Oak Press dates it to December 1846, while the Journal of San Diego History places it in late December 1846 or early January 1847. The journal names Juan Antonio and Cahuilla employed by the Lugo family as the attackers and describes the killings as retaliation for the earlier deaths of eleven Californios. Accounts differ on the number killed. The older journal account gives thirty-eight; the Pechanga study overview estimates as many as one hundred Luiseño/Temecula people. The City of Temecula's history also recounts the killing of about twenty prisoners who had surrendered. Philip St. George Cooke later recalled that Indigenous people had asked to accompany his battalion to bury those killed in the ambush. When the battalion arrived in the Temecula valley on January 25, 1847, Indigenous people had gathered for burial.

◯ General area onlyOpen case file →

Gilman Ranch and Jose Pope Adobe, Banning

⌖ Banning, California

Historic event / crimeStatus unconfirmed

On September 26, 1909, William Mike was shot and killed at Gilman Ranch in Banning. The Mike family had come for seasonal orchard work, and Willie Boy was also employed at the ranch. The killing set off a manhunt for Willie Boy. The story took different forms in the years that followed. Clara True's 1909 report described a deliberate shooting and claimed that Willie Boy later killed Carlota Mike and himself. Later historians dispute those claims; the shooting's circumstances, who killed Carlota and Willie Boy's ultimate fate remain contested.

◯ General area onlyOpen case file →
Add to the archive

Know a story worth telling?

Send a place name, its town, and a credible source link. Please don’t include private addresses, exact locations, or personal details.