← Back to the map / The case files
Case file 024 · Historical account; dates qualified in sources

Mesa Grande mountainside posse shootout

⌖ Mesa Grande, California

Historic event / crimeStatus unconfirmedGeneral area only

01Documented history

In September 1895, a posse pursued Ysidro Renterias after he wounded Ramon Arisa on September 6. Constable Hubbert and deputized citizen Juan Castro took part in the pursuit, which the Oceanside Blade described as lasting nine days. It ended in a confrontation at Mesa Grande, where Castro and Renterias died.

The Blade’s narrative places the confrontation on a Saturday. Robert Bowling’s 2022 account instead dates it to Sunday, September 15, and describes a pursuit of nearly ten days. Both accounts tell of Castro’s death during the effort to capture Renterias.

The Blade reported that an inquest the following day justified Hubbert’s actions. Both the Blade and the San Francisco Call credited him with killing Renterias. Bowling’s later account gives a different interpretation: it reports that the inquest found Hubbert’s bullet had not killed Renterias and infers simultaneous shots involving Castro.

02Legends and claims

No paranormal accounts are included in this profile.

03Visiting

Access unconfirmed

Confirm current access restrictions with the property owner before planning any visit.

The pin marks the approximate center of the general area, not an exact property location. Official public visitor information, where supplied, appears above.

Visitor notice: Not open to visitors unless officially stated. View from public areas only. Do not trespass.
Listing a place is not permission to enter private property or any closed building or cemetery. Many sites may be dangerous. Never trespass. Information may be incomplete or out of date.

04Sources

Source notes: Contemporary reports and a 2022 retrospective differ on the confrontation’s date and who fired the fatal shot.

  1. Death of Renterias and Castro, Oceanside Blade, September 21, 1895 — California Digital Newspaper Collection
  2. Hounds in Pursuit, San Francisco Call, November 17, 1895, page 4 — California Digital Newspaper Collection
  3. Never Forgotten: Juan Castro, Officer.com, October 22, 2022

On the map

◯ General area only · approximately 1 km across. Confirm access with the operator before visiting.

Information is based on public historical sources and may be out of date. Report a correction.

Add to the archive

Know a story worth telling?

Send a place name, its town, and a credible source link. Please don’t include private addresses, exact locations, or personal details.